Stefano Filletti challenges Miroslava Milenovic’s professional standing and alleged conflict of interest, while arguing Jeremy Harbinson’s failure to testify is delaying proceedings

Miroslava Milenovic
The defence representing Alfred Camilleri, Ronald Mizzi and Joseph Rapa in proceedings arising from the Vitals hospitals concession has asked the court to expunge evidence associated with two inquiry experts, raising objections over professional qualifications, an alleged conflict of interest and delays in securing testimony.
The requests were made by lawyer Professor Stefano Filletti at the first sitting before Magistrate Ann Marie Thake following the assignment of the case to her.
Opening his submissions, Filletti challenged the continued involvement of Miroslava Milenovic and Jeremy Harbinson, whose work formed part of the inquiry into the hospitals concession.
His first objection concerned Milenovic’s appointment and the capacity in which she had undertaken her work.
Filletti argued that a court-appointed expert acts as an extension of the court, assisting it through specialised knowledge. Where that work involves the exercise of a regulated profession, he submitted, the expert must possess the authorisation required to practise it.
Describing forensic accountancy as a specialisation within accountancy, Filletti argued that the designation did not remove the requirement to hold a professional warrant.
He referred to testimony by representatives of the Accountancy Board which, he said, established that Milenovic did not hold a Maltese accountancy warrant and that the qualifications examined did not entitle her to obtain one.
The defence maintained that a judicial appointment could not authorise an expert to perform work which the law reserved for warranted professionals.

Stefano Filletti
Filletti also referred to the Criminal Court’s decision ordering police action against Milenovic over allegations concerning her professional status and the work she had performed.
He questioned whether she could continue to be retained as an expert when criminal proceedings concerned the very capacity in which she had contributed to the evidence against the accused.
The defense argued that these matters had direct implications for her continued role in the case.
Alleged conflict of interest
Filletti raised a separate objection concerning what he described as a direct conflict of interest arising from the proceedings against Milenovic.
He argued that she was being prosecuted by the same state which relied on her evidence in proceedings against Camilleri, Mizzi and Rapa.
In the defence’s submission, an expert facing criminal proceedings brought by the state could find herself in a position of dependence on the prosecuting authorities while simultaneously being called upon to give evidence supporting another prosecution.
Filletti maintained that the potential consequences for her own liberty placed her in an untenable position and called her independence into question.
On those grounds, the defence requested the removal of her report and all testimony or evidence attributable to her, whether introduced directly or indirectly.

Jeremy Harbinson
Harbinson’s absence
Turning to Harbinson, Filletti argued that the expert’s continued failure to submit to questioning was unduly delaying the proceedings against his clients.
He referred to communications sent to the courts, including through Harbinson’s lawyers, which the defence said demonstrated that the expert knew his testimony was required but did not intend to testify.
Filletti characterised that conduct as deliberate evasion and argued that the accused could not be expected to wait indefinitely for a court-appointed expert to make himself available.
He also referred to Harbinson’s stated relinquishment of his professional warrant, which the defence said Harbinson had invoked among his reasons for being unable to testify.
The defence argued that the situation prevented proper questioning of the expert about his report and undermined the accused’s right to have their case determined within a reasonable time.
It therefore also requested the expunging of the evidence associated with Harbinson.
During the sitting, Magistrate Thake informed the parties that criminal proceedings against Milenovic had also been assigned to her.
The case was adjourned for a decree on the points raised.

